TOP 5 Best Electric Fireplace Insert Reviews

Do you already have your own classic-style fireplace, but don’t want to deal with the mess or the maintenance? How about all that smoke billowing around—not only potentially into your lungs, but into the environment through your chimney? Bring your fireplace into the 21st century with a beautiful electric fireplace insert. These electric fireplaces will fit into your existing mantle, so you’ll never have to sacrifice the style of your older, classic fireplace. Let’s take a look at the top 5 fireplace inserts:

Best Choice Products SKY1826 Embedded Fireplace Electric Insert

From a truly superior brand of electric fireplace, Best Choice, this innovative insert style of fireplace will let you have the heat and mesmerizing flames of a traditional fireplace without the cost or mess, and without sacrificing the attractive look of your beloved classic fireplace mantle. And unlike primitive fireplaces, there is no vent needed, so you can close up the chimney to save on heating costs.

As a modern answer to the fireplaces of yore, this product comes with a remote control so that you can turn the unit on or off at a distance. The intensity of the realistic flames are also adjustable with 5 different settings, and before you know it, you will have forgotten that your fireplace is artificial as you lie beside the glowing embers with the lifelike molded logs that are hand-finished for that personal touch that’s harder to get from a cookie-cutter product. There’s a charming panel of glass between you and the artificial flames, just to add an extra layer of sophistication.

Let this little heater brighten up your room and give it a warmness that previously only the crackle of a burning log could provide. You can choose between two different heat settings, and depending on what kind of night you’re having, you can also choose to simply watch the dancing flames without any heat at all. Don’t worry about things getting too hot, either, as there is a safety mechanism that gauges the internal temperature of the device and will turn it off if things get over-heated.

Installation of this beauty is very easy and is essentially a one-man job. No assembly is required at all and if you have any doubts, the included instruction manual that is filled with helpful images and advice will tell you everything you need to know.


  • Product weights about 29 lbs.
  • 21 x 28.5 x 5.7 inches in size.
  • CSA Certified.
  • Includes remote control.

Check price on Amazon


Golden Vantage 23″ 5200 BTU 1500W Adjustable Freestanding Tempered Glass Made Electric Stove Fireplace Heater w/ Remote Control Logs Set

Keep warm next to an authentic-looking electric fireplace that fits right into your existing mantle, and gives off a beautiful glow that will keep you awake staring at the flames for hours. This gorgeous model can be used as an insert or as a freestanding fireplace if you don’t have a pre-existing mantle of your own, but still want to enjoy the benefits of the flames and heat of a tradition fireplace without the mess or maintenance. It’s a great product to have around especially during the winter, but you can enjoy even in the summertime by turning off the heat and falling asleep to the mesmerizing light show made of realistic-looking artificial burning embers.

On the front of the unit, there are buttons that will control its two heat settings (which are also power settings) and you can easily decide on 750 Watts or 1500 Watts, depending on your needs and desires. Here, you will also find the on/off button for when you’re ready to turn in for the night. If you don’t feel like walking all the way up to your fireplace, however, you can optionally use the remote control, which can control brightness of the flames in the hearth. The logs inside the fireplace look extremely realistic and the LED flames put on an attractive show. The vent on this unit blows towards the front, and the glass in front of the hearth is tempered for durability. In case of emergency, this unit will also turn itself off if it finds that it is overheating, so you can keep your peace of mind as you take refuge from the cold. In addition, this fireplace is CSA certified.

Getting this unit up and running is easy, as the wiring simply involves plugging the fireplace into a standard outlet. It shouldn’t take longer than a few minutes to start enjoying your new fireplace.

Worried about what might happen if your brand new fireplace breaks? Don’t be; it comes with a one-year warranty that covers parts, so even if you find that your fireplace has failed you somehow, you can get it repaired. Rest easy knowing that your new purchase is durable, reliable, and that you’re covered in case anything goes wrong.


  • 8.2 x 23 x 17.2 inches in size.
  • About 28 lbs in weight.
  • Includes remote.
  • Can work as insert or freestanding.
  • Two heat settings.

Check price on Amazon



ClassicFlame 23″ Infrared Electric Insert 23II210GRA

Looking for an attractive, realistic-looking insert for your already-existent 23” mantle? Have a room that is 1,000 square feet or less inside that just seems to get disproportionately cold, but you don’t want to run the fireplace because it’s too much trouble? You can’t go wrong with this unit. Get all of the benefits of a fireplace that you’re looking for, all the heat and beautiful flames of a classic, traditional fireplace, without all of the hassle. Simply install this electric fireplace insert into your mantle and let the artificial flames put on a light show just for you and your loved ones, in the cozy privacy of your living room, or whichever room already includes a pre-built, traditional 23” mantle.

The logs on this unit are particularly realistic, and you could swear that those are real embers eating up the wood before your very eyes—all that’s missing is the comforting smell of burning trees, but you’re probably not going to miss the smoke with how convenient this electric fireplace is. You can use the unit with or without heat if you prefer just to view the flames, and there is a thermometer that will tell you the fireplace’s current temperature (though there is no thermostat to change it, unfortunately). If you let this fireplace run for long enough, it can heat up a room of impressive size—up to 1,000 square feet of space. (Though some product reviewers claim that it may heat a little less; adjust expectations accordingly.) The flames themselves have several different settings, so you can decide what sort of intensity you are looking for—you can watch a dazzling light show, or you can fall asleep to the soft glowing of embers in the dead of night.

Save energy, time, and hassle and modernize your fireplace by getting this insert. It is very efficient, much more efficient than a traditional fireplace that relies of the combustion of wood, and it may even save you some money since you won’t have to have a central heater on as much during cold nights. Why run up your power bill when you can just snuggle up close to the “fire” and feel the warm air blowing on you as you watch the flames flickering? Most users report that it doesn’t raise their electric bill too much, comparable to running the air conditioning in the summer.


  • 23.7 x 9.3 x 20 inches in size.
  • About 27.4 lbs in weight.
  • Heats up to 1,000 square feet, according to manufacturer.
  • Functions as insert.
  • Can be used to upgrade if you own 23” mantels by ClassicFlame already

Check price on Amazon

AKDY 23″ Black Electric Firebox Fireplace Heater Insert

Want a firebox with a raging flame that can be inserted in your traditional fireplace mantel to convert it into a fully-electric, emission-free, efficient, and easy-to-use artificial fireplace? Why don’t you give this unit a try, then? It comes with everything you need to turn those cold nights at home during the dead of winter into cozy memories by the fire, without all of the hassle and mess of a classic fireplace. You don’t have to sacrifice looks, either, as you can put this fireplace straight into your existing mantel that can handle a 23” firebox.

This fireplace features a patented technology in its flame display, which is extremely realistic and will remind you of your traditional fireplace as you watch it glowing in the dark. Many users comment on its beauty and the relaxing feeling that the flickering elicits.

It includes are remote that you can use to turn the unit on or off at a distance if you wish, and all of the settings are extremely easy to adjust using this unit’s intuitive controls, including the heat and the intensity of the flames. There is also a timer that you can set to automatically turn the unit off if you find that you would like to fall asleep by the fireplace, but don’t want hot air blowing towards you for the entirety of the night.

There is no assembly required either, and you only need to make some minor installation steps to get started, which are all highlighted in the easy to understand instruction manual on the manufacturer’s website. No complicated wiring system; all you have to do is plug it into the nearest outlet and you are ready to use your new fireplace. As a result, you can put this fireplace anywhere in your house that has a mantle, and it can very easy to transport to a new location if the need arises.

This fireplace is a powerful 1400 Watts and is controlled by a thermostat. Heat up those cold spots in your house with something much more attractive than a space heater, something the brings together both classic aesthetic and new technology. If you already have a mantle to house it, look into getting this lovely fireplace insert as an upgrade.


  • 23.8 x 7.1 x 20.2 inches in size.
  • About 29.5 lbs in weight.
  • Remote control included.
  • 1400 Watts.
  • Plug and play wiring.

Check price on Amazon

28″ Infrared Insert 28II200GRA INSERT

Already have a 28” fireplace mantel and looking for just the firebox to fill it and bring it back to life? Maybe you live fireplaces, but don’t want to deal with all the work involved, or the clean-up, or the smoke. Maybe you have a pretty mantle with no vent, intended only for show, and you want to give it some purpose by letting it become not only your space heater, but your source of mood-lighting at night.

Whatever your reason, if you’re looking for a 28” fireplace insert that will give you electric heat and a beautiful, realistic flame, you might want to give this unit some serious consideration. The vast majority of users who have purchased this fireplace are satisfied, and they compare it favorably to other brands that may not have held up to their initial promise of a realistic look.

This fireplace has includes Spectra-fire flame technology, making the flame extremely realistic, so you’re unlikely to miss the wood and the crackle of your old fireplace. Even the beautifully-crafted logs look genuine, so when it comes to aesthetics, you can trust that this firebox will deliver and give whichever room your choose to place it in the kind of classic flair that you’re looking for. The insert is a muted black color with dark artificial bricks lining the inside, just as you would expect from a traditional fireplace.

Unlike traditional fireplaces, however, heating is optional with this unit, and you can always just turn off the heat and simply watch the flames, so you can enjoy the fireplace in an season without worrying about the room getting too hot. The flames come with many options, and you can choose from 5 different intensities, so you can keep your fireplace running exactly as you want it to. The fireplace will heat a room of up to 1,000 square feet, so you can stay warm even in a large living room and you won’t have to always sit right next to the hearth to feel the comforting heat.

So if you’re looking for something to fill up that cold, empty mantle this winter (or heck, even this summer), you would do well to consider this fireplace insert unit. It’s realistic, durable, and heats quite decently.


  • 29.1 x 10.3 x 23.1 inches in size.
  • About 29 lbs in weight.
  • Fits a 28” mantle.
  • Uses LED’s to save a lot of energy.
  • Will heat a room of up to 1,000 square feet.

Check price on Amazon



Spread the love